For a Next.js app starting in November 2026, Better Auth is the most direct starting point. The framework is free under the MIT license, it keeps users in your own database and covers what most SaaS products need — email and password, social providers, magic links, passkeys, 2FA and organizations — without a per-user bill. The Next.js setup is one auth.ts file, an /api/auth/[...all] route and a React client.

Clerk removes the auth database from your servers: sign-in screens, organization management and compliance are hosted. Its free plan covers 50,000 retained users per app; Pro costs $25 a month, or $20 billed annually (Clerk pricing). For a new project, Auth.js is not the starting point: the project moved under Better Auth's responsibility on September 22, 2025, and the Auth.js docs recommend Better Auth for new projects (announcement). It still fits one specific case: a signed session with no database.

Prices, limits and GitHub stars below come from the official pages and the GitHub API on November 6, 2026. All three vendors change their offers regularly, so check the vendor page before you commit to an annual plan.

The comparison at a glance#

Criterion Notre choixBetter AuthAuth.jsClerk
ModelOpen source, self-hosted frameworkOpen source libraryHosted authentication service
LicenseMITISCProprietary service
PriceFree framework; managed infrastructure free on Starter, then $20/month on ProFreeFree up to 50,000 retained users per app; Pro $25/month ($20 annual); Business $300/month ($250 annual)
DatabaseYours: SQLite, PostgreSQL, MySQL; Drizzle, Prisma or MongoDB adaptersYours, or none in stateless modeManaged by Clerk
MethodsEmail/password, social, magic link, passkeys, 2FA, organizations, API keysOAuth/OIDC, email, magic link, passkeys, credentialsSocial, email, code, magic link, password, passkeys and MFA on Pro
Next.js integrationRoute handler, React client, Next.js 16 proxy[...nextauth] route handler, Next.js 16 proxyCLI, ClerkProvider, Next.js 16 proxy
Screens includedNo, you build the UINo, you build the UIYes, prebuilt components
Multi-tenancyOrganizations pluginBuild it yourselfYes, 100 monthly retained organizations (MRO) and 20 members per organization; B2B add-on $100/month
GitHub stars30.6k28.4kNot applicable
Best forKeeping accounts and control, with no per-user costAn existing NextAuth app or a database-free sessionShipping an MVP with ready-made screens and a B2B team
Editorial comparison — public prices checked in November 2026, in US dollars before tax. Free plans and limits are the ones listed on the official pages on that date.