For a new React project in November 2026, the first decision is who owns the component code and who absorbs the updates. If you already use Tailwind CSS and want a design system that looks like your product, shadcn/ui is the most direct starting point. If you are building an admin app with forms, dates, notifications and tables, Mantine ships those pieces in four packages, while shadcn/ui leaves you to wire them. If your team thinks in tokens, recipes and accessible primitives, Chakra UI still fits, provided you accept Emotion and its trade-offs.
All three are free and MIT-licensed. None of them charges a per-seat license: the invoice arrives as engineering time spent wiring, migrating and maintaining styles. We checked versions, GitHub stars, npm downloads and paid add-ons on the official pages and APIs on November 6, 2026. Chakra Pro and Mantine UI are separate block catalogs, not requirements for using the core library. The numbers below come from the shadcn/ui changelog, the Mantine homepage, the Chakra UI changelog, the GitHub API and the npm downloads API.
The comparison at a glance#
| Criterion | Notre choixshadcn/ui | Mantine | Chakra UI |
|---|---|---|---|
| Model | Code distribution | Component and hook library | Component system |
| License | MIT | MIT | MIT |
| Core price | Free | Free | Free |
| Paid add-on | None for the core | Mantine UI free (123 blocks) | Chakra Pro $299 personal, $899 team, one-time |
| Styling | Tailwind CSS and CSS variables | CSS Modules and PostCSS preset, no runtime | Emotion, tokens and recipes |
| Primitives | Base UI by default since July 2026; Radix and React Aria supported | In-house components, Floating UI | Ark UI 5.40 |
| Components | 66 in the Base UI docs | 120+ components and 70+ hooks | Around 100 components and snippets |
| Forms | React Hook Form, TanStack Form or Formisch | @mantine/form, 6.3 kB minified and compressed with gzip | Field and snippets, form library up to you |
| Dates and notifications | Dates and charts included, the rest is assembly | Dates, notifications, charts, Tiptap, Spotlight | Dates and rich text editor; charts in a separate module |
| Next.js 16 | CLI init and App Router | App Router guide and template | Docs for Next.js 15 and 16, Node 20 |
| GitHub stars | 127.5k | 31.9k | 40.7k |
| npm downloads | Not comparable: the CLI is not the library | 12.8M/month for @mantine/hooks | 6.8M/month for @chakra-ui/react |
| Best for | A custom design system | A complete admin application | A token-driven design system |



Comments
Loading comments…